I agree with Evil_J on this. but I'll go one step further: Since a guide quest requires the participation of many participants, it makes no sense to have the reward be less than say an explorer bringing back 35 presents from a extra long search. If the guild is going to put in the effort, the reward should be comparable.Quote:
Originally Posted by Evil_J
Anywho I guess I will contribute by saying what I said before. Why not have guild quests and event guild quests?
yes I would like event resources instead of guild coins during the event
I think it is unwise to mess with the current guild quest system until all of the numerous unresolved bugs have been dealt with. Some of these bugs have been annoying us for years with seemingly no will on the devs part to correct them.
the explorers should bring the players Eggs , like they brought us Presents. I'd say keep the guild coins as they are
The fact that players have been limited to the amount of things game has allowed to buy with guild coins has ruined it. Many players are sitting on guild coins that are almost worthless to them because of that. So many say why should i do them.
Event resources are better because it helps people that aren't in guilds gain strength & also gets lower power players a chance to get a taste of the items that are available at higher levels.
Um, yeah. You either have to re-read the original post or clarify why guild quests rewarding event resources helps people not in guilds.Quote:
Originally Posted by Grumbledorf
Why not just give people the choice of event resources/guild coins as rewards, once they have completed the quest. Then everyone would be happy :).
So.... let me get this right... just scrap all form of guild quest earning guild coin during events?! Makes no sense to me. Perhaps those not in guilds would be the most affected in an event; though I have to agree with the early post(s) that in the decisions of guilds and the subsequent rewards, those not in a guild should have NO say! I am not sure this poll was completely thought through before going live.
On that note, I thing that the results displayed for this poll should have not only the player's selection shown but if they are currently a member of a guild. I think that it would make for an interesting contrast.
Voted for keeping guild coins, and I see that the current poll numbers has my vote as the low vote. Not very happy about that, I bet most are voting for event resources that really don't understand or are on the low end during events. Many long time players know what happens when these type of changes are brought in.
I voted yes for event resources, but only if it will be reasonable event resources reward. As many mentioned here, ratio needs to be added when asking people opinion. Get ready for some serious complaining if the event resource reward is ridiculously low (as we've been noticing in other areas when it comes to rewards).
No event resources from guild quests. No way.
But smaller guilds already are rewarded less guild coins than larger guilds. Nature of the beast, and incentive to grow your guild.
Moin,
leave things as they are...
Guild Quest = Guild Coins...
I wish I could change my vote,
the resources would be a much better choice, as it will help players more, specially the new ones who do not have a lot of explorers / scouts to send out hunting presents. it would also give those in a guild incentive to finish the quest quickly to get more rewards.
As long as they make it worth while for the loss of the guild coins
those with out guilds have no profit either way, and should not vote
+1 Well put. Personally, I am currently riding the 'Keep the Guild Coins' train until I see some numbers that are compelling to change that opinion. -PeaceQuote:
Originally Posted by Snacknado
and btw, why would those not in a guild have a say in guild coin matters? Makes no sense.
lets not forget we are getting- 1 Present = 0.4 gold coins 1 event collectible = 0.04 gold coins, so it is 2 coins per 5 presents, and 2 coins per 50 collectibles- for our leftover presents/collectibles when event ends. Why would "We will then look into how everything can be balanced and made fair to everyone."be any different? That return is even worse than spending 350 gems for 100 gold coins in gem shop....
Greetings fellow Settlers.
I have found that from noticing so many guilds going crazy on who they invite or who they do or don't kick out to be a bother to the game itself. I have been kicked a few times and left a few times and if you ask me personally, I do not care for guild coins.
Guild coins was just an excuse for some leaders to make being active a requirement! I play at my own speed, my own terms and I do very well. I found trading
to be the advantage I needed. In our guild (BWT) not one person feels they have to play everyday! Real life is more important than any game. And some of them leave and we don't know why and we just move on and invite more players. Number grow slowly because many actually want more help and well one thing we do not do is babysit them. Guild coins in my opinion was just a way for guild leaders to demand activity. I never cared for them guild coins because I buy Gems. I also have helped over 1000 players on the game by giving out deals for 1 fish/stone and continue to give out for free. I offer these freebies because I have a lot and sharing is more important to me than activity rules.
If the trade off for guild coins is a fair exchange for any event item, then I vote for the event exchange. But if BB wants to steal the guild coins from them players who do bust their butts on doing guild quests, then I vote against it, leave their guild coins alone!
I guess the question I have to ask BB is very simple, if you plan to make it optional for all players to turn in their guild coins or to keep them, then that's a 50/50 fair deal, then some would and some would not. But for me, I never found anything worth spending guild coins on because I rock my game and have more than I need, so I am doing much better than most.
Keep your game at your own speed as long as you are having fun :)
LMM (BWT) Guild Leader
we want event resources!! we want event resources!! we want event resources!!
Pay 30 cannon and complete 2 Adventures get a pine log. Nice
Hello everyone,
Thank you for the votes and comments, I find this very interesting.
We will share more information with you after the poll ends, we will need some time to compile all the results.
BB_Endesmor
Poll numbers show about 3 to 1 in favor of event resources, yet the posts here seem to show the opposite trend. Maybe some people voted without thinking things through completely first.
BB, there are some good insights here that should all be carefully considered before making hasty changes.
+1Quote:
Originally Posted by ARM1
Hello everyone,
Yes, I agree. I have read every single comment and all the details will be forwarded to my colleagues.Quote:
Originally Posted by ARM1
BB_Endesmor
I do agree with the price hike.... Just as you said, people will ask an arm and a leg in trad for a wee bit of grout. (( Do to the 600 gem price to buy only 200 worth of grout. )) I did like that they put it up in the Christmas event. that helped but still not easy to come up with presents to buy all that we need for the upgrades of the new improved watermill. farms silos and many other items.... so, i do like guild coins but if they make the resource worth the trouble of going after it... for the event... i dont mind.... :)
Hello,
SweaterPuppies, this is only a Sneak Peek and an early version of the feature, it may not reflect the final status of the content.
We made the decision to include this change in the new test version based on the poll results.
This is an opportunity for everyone to try the new features and share valuable feedback with us. We want to gather as much feedback as possible to make this feature enjoyable for all Settlers.
BB_Endesmor
Wow - I agree 100% with you on this one. BB did not care about player's desire, they had this stinking event take-over from the beginning. This vote was a complete sham and already decided. I was talking with lots of players and from the informal count it was a 2:1 in favor of keeping guild coin (I only considered those in guilds) and the vote here shows almost 3:1 against. How does that happen?Quote:
Originally Posted by SweaterPuppies
Thanks for the LACK of consideration, BB.
Really??? Please! The polls are still warm from the counting and magically, the Easter 2016 event has it all ready to go???? Bah.Quote:
Originally Posted by BB_Endesmor
No surprise, however.
I vote for event resources during the events. As commented by others, the amount does make a difference. It does not have to be huge but proportional to make it worth it. 5 eggs no way, but at least 50 to start with.