I used three Potion of Endless Energy - two on Finesmiths and one on Colorful Finesmith.
Only the two on the Finesmiths counted. The one on Colorful Finesmith did not, so I needed to use another Potion to complete the quest.
As very few players have a Pathfinder and a Colorful Finesmith, I'm not sure how you would duplicate the error, but I have them both and had this today.
Thank you,
KH
